Mon 08 Jun 2020, 23:20
I'll expand upon an old answer I wrote on this from the old forums.
Since I'm heavily invested in the main area of the game, Wilderland I would favour region expansions on and around that place. I would love to see more on the wild places and what one might find and do there. I could envision more done on Mirkwood, that endless depth of green and darkness. The Long Lake area and The Long Marshes could be expanded upon. I don’t even really understand the basic shape, or form, or even concept of the Long Lake as it stands from the maps there are to be honest. The Misty Mountains and The Grey Mountains and that which lies beyond them – The Withered Heath and The Waste could all be done a lot more with. I could also envision an entire campaign supplement on the Vales of Gundabad alone. If we look south I would like to know much more about The Brown Lands.
In keeping with the focus on existing parts of the campaign world and with the tone of the world, I also envision a campaign supplement that dives more into what sort of ruins can be found in Wilderland and maybe Eriador as well (greatly expanding the snippet in the Journeys & Maps supplement), with specific, as well as generic, examples and suggestions on how they might figure into campaigns.
Of course, I would also love to learn more of the civilised lands to the east, especially since that is where I would assume most of the trade of the north moves to and fro - Dorwinion and the Easterlings of Rhûn and beyond. With trade would follow people and influences, things that would be very exciting to see incorporated over time into a campaign. I also agree that the last inhabited place to be described in Wilderland, Lórien, needs to be done.
Finally, Eriador as it was described in Rivendell was a huge let-down for me. It was just too empty. I find it totally immersion breaking, despite the fairy-tale aspects of Tolkiens works, that The Shire and The Dúnedain could exist in almost literal isolation from anything else, being surrounded by naught but great, empty Lone-lands. I get that there’s no nations left, but villages, farmsteads, something. Or at least give me a ton of ruins to explore and have reasons to do so from what few residents there are left, but no, pretty much nothing. I would like Eriador to be revisited frankly.
You know, just a few more books... You can probably tell that I really am not done with Wilderland and not greatly interested in Gondor or errantries. Moria would be cool too of course.