Forum

I run the 5e version and I have a player that their only frame of reference for RPGs is Baldur's Gate 3. Started a group of heros off at level 1 and my BG3 player quits after one session because "there isn't enough magic". He wants fireball and other such spells, like in BG3. I tried to explain that even in D&D a level 1 character isn't going to have fireball or flashy spells. No one in the group had played d&d or LOTR 5e before, which is why we started at level 1. Now, I did a session 0 thing explaining the style of LOTR and this person likes and knows about LOTR, which is why they joined. This person told me they wanted more magic. (They were a dwarf scholar.) I told them that was good feedback and there were definitely ways we could make the character more magical, like with the broken spells virtue or an item with a blessing, or a magical weapon.

But it just left me crestfallen, after their abrupt departure 30 minutes before the monthly game started. Maybe the way this person left just has me feeling this way. My remaining two players are really invested, take notes, and are enjoying the game, so yay for that.

Hi BlueWizard1,
check out the homebrewn "Istari of Valinor - Heroic Culture" for your player: https://ko-fi.com/s/a5c1caeaad
And one of the latest OtherMinds issues features a really great article about the Istari, which should provide more than enough background for introducing more magic to your gameplay: https://www.otherminds.net/downloads/ot ... art:int=20
It's quite sophisticated, though.
Good luck and keep us posted how that dwarf scholar becomes a mighty wizard one day... provided that player gets it, that, to my understanding, Middle-earth is a place of "high fantasy and low magic", but if magic happens, it is usually way more impressive/beautiful/dramatic than in any other fantasy realm. I still remember the awe-struck faces of my players, when Nellie Longarm (a Troll Hole, TftLL) made fog (with some green sparks) over that lake in Morglynd. It was the only magic occuring in that adventure, and it was just awesome.

Hi BlueWizard1,
check out the homebrewn "Istari of Valinor - Heroic Culture" for your player: https://ko-fi.com/s/a5c1caeaad
And one of the latest OtherMinds issues features a really great article about the Istari, which should provide more than enough background for introducing more magic to your gameplay: https://www.otherminds.net/downloads/ot ... art:int=20
It's quite sophisticated, though.
Good luck and keep us posted how that dwarf scholar becomes a mighty wizard one day... provided that player gets it, that, to my understanding, Middle-earth is a place of "high fantasy and low magic", but if magic happens, it is usually way more impressive/beautiful/dramatic than in any other fantasy realm. I still remember the awe-struck faces of my players, when Nellie Longarm (a Troll Hole, TftLL) made fog (with some green sparks) over that lake in Morglynd. It was the only magic occuring in that adventure, and it was just awesome.

Hi BlueWizard1,
check out the homebrewn "Istari of Valinor - Heroic Culture" for your player: https://ko-fi.com/s/a5c1caeaad
And one of the latest OtherMinds issues features a really great article about the Istari, which should provide more than enough background for introducing more magic to your gameplay: https://www.otherminds.net/downloads/ot ... art:int=20
It's quite sophisticated, though.
Good luck and keep us posted how that dwarf scholar becomes a mighty wizard one day... provided that player gets it, that, to my understanding, Middle-earth is a place of "high fantasy and low magic", but if magic happens, it is usually way more impressive/beautiful/dramatic than in any other fantasy realm. I still remember the awe-struck faces of my players, when Nellie Longarm (a Troll Hole, TftLL) made fog (with some green sparks) over that lake in Morglynd. It was the only magic occuring in that adventure, and it was just awesome.

Sorry,what I want to say is a little off-topic but I have to ask.This Will at the World's End source is amazing, I wish there was a 5e edition of the content available here, since my group (old D&D guys) plays it, and I’d be happy to support the creator. Do you happen to know where I can reach him, maybe here on the forum?

Hi BlueWizard1,
check out the homebrewn "Istari of Valinor - Heroic Culture" for your player: https://ko-fi.com/s/a5c1caeaad
And one of the latest OtherMinds issues features a really great article about the Istari, which should provide more than enough background for introducing more magic to your gameplay: https://www.otherminds.net/downloads/ot ... art:int=20
It's quite sophisticated, though.
Good luck and keep us posted how that dwarf scholar becomes a mighty wizard one day... provided that player gets it, that, to my understanding, Middle-earth is a place of "high fantasy and low magic", but if magic happens, it is usually way more impressive/beautiful/dramatic than in any other fantasy realm. I still remember the awe-struck faces of my players, when Nellie Longarm (a Troll Hole, TftLL) made fog (with some green sparks) over that lake in Morglynd. It was the only magic occuring in that adventure, and it was just awesome.

...

Hey Runang, I checked out this Istari of Valinor Heroic Culture homebrew yesterday. It's really interesting. Wow, there's a lot of imagination and a lot of work involved. Who made this?! They deserve congratulations. There's a lot of potential for roleplaying here. The Istari character can discover their powers without being aware that He is a demigod (it's certain that their time in Middle-earth makes them mortal for the moment). You can play on the fact that the character might feel like an imposter (at times). Wow, so many ideas come to mind with this Heroic Culture. It can take time to find the right mage's staff that gives them 100% of their powers (I can easily imagine a staff that gives 50% of their powers for the first staff found). The mage has to go on a quest to find the right staff. Wow, so many ideas! Thanks for finding this amazing gem.

Arthur.