Forum

Perhaps a little bit of calm and consideration might be called for. Speculating in categorical statements on what others actually mean by their texts or really are interested in isn't conducive to a constructive discussion — on either side.


A clarification could indeed also be called for.

The way the history currently reads, at least to me, is as follows: NATO moves troops into Poland; these meet stiff resistance from the enemy and crumble over time down to at best 10% of their original power, losing their armour to depleted spare part reserves and their artillery to depleted ammo.
"Operation Reset" collects the last scattered remnants into a cohesive force and launches an offensive. In spite of initial successes, managing to cut the Soviets off from command and supply lines, they still face a superior enemy — who, to boot, somehow retains both armour and artillery — and are finally annihilated, the last few survivors fleeing into the woods.
Thus, in the end, the Soviets have during the course of the war obliterated all the combined NATO forces that have moved into Poland, while still themselves managing to maintain unit cohesion.

Now, if this summary does not reflect the story as it's intended to read, then yes: a clarification might be a good idea.
If it does, then it obviously doesn't need any clarification. But it does in that case imply a ... let us say, very powerful Soviet Union.


Not all of us are engaged in discussions on other forums or in social media ... for my own part, I am neither; nor do I know who (if any) are. But as for the present context, I am sure we would all hope to see a continued discussion in a mutually constructive spirit.
Hence the question: if other avenues to reach a final environment that fulfils the requirements of the core premise, but also fixes the plausibility issues in the back story that some of us have argued for on basis of factual military history etc — would there be an interest to keep an open mind towards amending the backstory? Or is deeper feedback on the worldbuilding actually undesired; rendering any and all discussion on the backstory meaningless from the outset?

On 16 September of a unspecified year in the 1980s, the United States conducts an orbital test of the new Space Ranger antimissile laser defense system. American scientist Burt Gains oversees the test under the aegis of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency with the target warhead being launched from Vandenberg Air Force Base as the international media covers it. After the Space Ranger module successfully destroys the warhead, the crew of the Space Voyager shuttle carrying the module returns to worldwide adulation. Gains looks at the successful test as a sign that nuclear war can be prevented, but has reservations about its potential to inflame the nuclear arms race. His sister Laura and his best friend Wataru Mikumo soon find out that he was kidnapped by Soviet spies while heading off to work. A Soviet Alfa-class submarine is tasked to transport Burt to Vladivostok. Seeing the danger of Burt forced to replicate his Space Ranger work for the Soviets, US President Gibson orders the submarine sunk with nuclear torpedoes.

Tension builds up between the US and the USSR in the wake of the sinking, with President Gibson attempting a peaceful solution with the Soviets, who promptly put their forces in Eastern Europe on high alert. Wataru is promoted to lead the Space Ranger research team as Laura is medically confined due to depression over her brother's death.

On Christmas Eve, the Soviets get the news that an elite Soviet Air Force pilot has defected, flying the USSR's most advanced strike aircraft, the Black Dragon, to a West German Air Force base in West Germany. Fearful of NATO acquiring Black Dragon's technology, the Soviets launch a Spetsnaz commando raid to kill the pilot and destroy the plane. The raid is but the first act of the Soviets and the Warsaw Pact going into battle, easily blasting across West Germany and the Low Countries, eventually capturing Paris.

The Soviets keep up the offensive, with attacks on Iran, Turkey, and the other parts of the Middle East to capture oil resources while launching airstrikes on Japan; China joins the war as well, ordering PLA forces to attack the USSR's Far East region. US forces invade Cuba. Soviet First Deputy Premier Kutuzov convenes the Politburo on Premier Orlov's behalf and proposes a ceasefire to secure oil rights to the Middle East while plotting to arrest Defense Minister Bulgarin, who earlier pushed Orlov to go to war. However, Bulgarin appears and has the entire Politburo arrested.

A Soviet Navy ballistic missile submarine receives orders to launch on the US, but comes under attack from the US Navy and sustains heavy damage. Waiting for a recall order from Premier Orlov himself, the submarine captain refuses to launch the missiles, but with the sub rapidly sinking, his executive officer kills him and completes the launch with his communications officer. Several US cities are destroyed in the attack and President Gibson authorizes a limited nuclear counterstrike. Bulgarin launches a second strike while one of his assistants kills Orlov as he tries to negotiate peace with Gibson over the hotline. The Soviet attack hits more US and allied cities, with casualties estimated at 20 million. Gibson learns that Vandenberg is still safe and authorizes the Space Ranger's deployment with Wataru sent up as well. Meanwhile, survivors in the war zones begin a peace movement together with deserting soldiers. When Bulgarin learns that the deserters include Soviet and Warsaw Pact troops, he prepares to launch all remaining Soviet nuclear missiles, but Kutuzov reappears in a bid to force him to stop. Bulgarin is killed, but not before he presses the launch button with the override canceled.

Word of the new strike inbound reaches Gibson and the Space Ranger forces, with four modules in orbit to stop the warheads. While the satellites destroy many MIRV warheads, three are destroyed by the Soviets' killer satellite network and one warhead severely damages the fourth and the Space Voyager shuttle. Wataru decides to head to the last remaining satellite and repair it ahead of another wave of MIRVs before his oxygen runs out. The module is repaired and Wataru shoots down seven MIRVs, but is forced to maneuver the satellite to get close and shoot down the eighth bearing down on Los Angeles, but the blast shakes him loose from the module and out into space. Laura, who was evacuated to the US after being caught in the Soviet airstrikes on Japan, flies in another shuttle to save Wataru while Kutuzov orders the crew of a nearby Soviet space station to rescue him.

Any description of the state of the world becomes canon when it's put into the game. This is the foundation that all other writers must conform to when writing new modules. If that foundation isn't solid, different writers will/might stray away in different directions creating an inconsistent world.

But if you want a larger scale, the official timeline becomes the constraint the new stuff has to fit into.

As long as there is no meta-plot, everything not in a module series assumes the same start point, etc.