Forum

Hi! I am interested in how you guys view these two points:
1. Do days in-between journey events each provide the "Prolonged rest"? If so, should we assume that the heroes regain their health between events on all journeys?
Really interested in knowing how loremasters view this, since I've been gobbling up the rules for the past few days and have some contradictions on my mind.

How do you implement sightseeing, shown for example in the North Downs table (p. 197), into what is, presumably, a journey?

More specifically: how do you count time during exploration, do you allow short and long rests, do you treat the table event like a Landmark (possibly hanging around for a couple of days), etc.?

Just my 2 quick cents on the first topic: Good point. Never thought about that. The question I would ask myself is: why should every night during a journey NOT count as if the party would do a prolonged rest (at least as long as no ghosts or any other nightmares are disturbing their night's rest)? Time is time and rest is rest, regardless in which situation it takes place.

Try not to let the rules push you around too much. Remember they work for you, not the other way around. Most things are obvious and don't require rules to decide. Logic and creativity are enough. When they aren't, you have the rules. (See "When to Roll" on page 16.)

I have a related question - do you only apply fatigue at the end of a journey? Reading the rules, I would say yes, but that feels unsatisfying.

In my last game my solo player travelled from Rivendell to Isengard - a journey on foot of about a month. I used the Strider mode rules to deal with travel events (these are great by the way), and one of those that came up as a result of a terrible travel roll was an encounter with a wraith near Ost-in-Edhil. The player had some fortunate rolls and was able to defeat the wraith, but it occurred to me that the fatigue built up in the journey so far played no part in the fight. In reality the PC would already be somewhat fatigued from two weeks of travelling, and that would make endurance loss push them closer to being Weary. But playing RAW it doesn't play a part.

Also, at the end of the journey the PC is able to rest long enough for the fatigue to be recovered (it's not exactly a haven, but it's not a hostile location at this point, and the PC is a welcome guest). So the journey fatigue will just be recovered before the next journey, making it a bit pointless.

I'm considering just applying fatigue directly as it is rolled on future journeys. I will still allow a travel roll to recover some fatigue when reaching the destination, and I'll probably allow the PC to allocate fatigue to a mount (if they have one) instead of to themselves, as they see fit.

If I understood Fatigue correctly - each increase of Fatigue is an immediate decrease of Endurance. After resting, your Endurance is limited by the Fatigue you have. This effectively means that you become Weary sooner, since you can't take as many points of damage before dropping beneath the "Load" value.
To summarize: longer Journeys = more Events = more Fatigue = more danger.