I rolled for a Wondrous item which has two blessings. I got 5 and then 5 which would be a Ring of Riddle (+2d on Riddle roles) and for the second blessing got the same thing! another 5 and a 6.
So, I could just roll again, or perhaps this is an exceptionally mysterious item which grants 4d?! or 3d? for Riddle. How do you interpret it if you roll the same thing twice?
BTW, my character has 0 for Riddle currently. I also want to make this useful to the characters overarching quest of finding the killer of his father and brother. Could Riddle be used to figure out things like that? He has a few clues, the sword they were killed with, and has been "cursed to not like what you will find out" but not much else. I guess rolling Riddle would help get more clues?
Ideas?