User avatar
Smog
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri 03 Jul 2020, 19:03
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Mon 20 Jul 2020, 20:30

I'm not sure Tolkien was entirely consistent here with the published legendarium. The Silvan language does continue to dominate in Lothlórien. However, by the end of the Third Age Sindarin becomes the dominant language of the Mirkwood Elves with little remaining of Silvan except some place names and perhaps personal names.

I absolutely agree that the Legendarium was not always consistent in regards to Sindarin's evolution through the ages and across the many regions and peoples that spoke it; though I was not specifically speaking to the adoption of languages in my previous post, but rather the broader cultural merging that took place between the two.

That said, in regards to Sindarin in the Silvan realms specifically, Tolkien was never terribly consistent on this issue, even within short periods of time near the end of his life. For example:

"... at the end of the Third Age there were prob. more people (Men) that knew Q. (Quenya), or spoke S. (Sindarin), than there were Elves who did either! Though dwindling, the population of Minas Tirith and its fiefs must have been much greater than that of Lindon, Rivendell, and Lorien.*
*The Silvan Elves of Thranduil's realm did not speak S.(Sindarin) but a related language or dialect"
-The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 347, p. 425

and also:

"... but they still remembered that they were in origin Eldar, members of the Third Clan, and they welcomes those of the Noldor and especially the Sindar who did not pass over the Sea but migrated eastward [i.e. at the beginning of the Second Age]. Under the leadership of these they became again ordered folk and increased in wisdom. Thranduil father of Legolas of the Nine Walkers was Sindarin, and that tongue was used in his house, though not by all his folk."

which then continues to elaborate on Lorien:

"In Lorien, where many of the people were Sindar in origin, or Noldor, survivors from Eregion, Sindarin had become the language of all the people. In what way their Sindarin differed from the forms of Beleriand -- see FR II 6, where Frodo reports that the speech of the Silvan folk that they used among themselves was unlike that of the West -- is not of course now known. It probably differed in little more than what would now be popularly called 'accent': mainly differences of vowel-sounds and intonation sufficient to mislead one who, as Frodo, was not well acquainted with purer Sindarin. There may of course also have been some local words and other features ultimately due to the influence of the former Silvan tongue ..."

but then Tolkien said the following in a recorded discussion from approximately the same period:

"By the end of the Third Age the Silvan tongues had probably ceased to be spoken in the two regions that had importance at the time of the War of the Ring: Lorien and the realm of Thranduil in northern Mirkwood."
-Unfinished Tales, "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", "Appendix A: The Silvan Elves and their Speech", pp. 256-7

In summary, the differences seem to range from small and dialectal in the case of Lorien to outright Sindarin rejection in the case of some of Thranduil's people, while in other writings Tolkien claimed Silvan had completely disappeared in these realms. I do not have a strong personal opinion (or even preference) on the issue due to so many writings being entirely contradictory, as seen above. In fact, in regards to this exact problem, Christopher went on to say the following:

Nowhere (I believe) is it made clear how the adoption of the Silvan speech by the Sindarin rulers of the Silvan Elves of Mirkwood, as described (in my previous post, as quoted by Otaku), is to be related to the statement cited (above) that by the end of the Third Age Silvan Elvish had ceased to be spoken in Thranduil's realm.
-Unfinished Tales, "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", "Appendix B: The Sindarin Princes of the Silvan Elves", pp. 259-60

In summary, this is just another instance where the Professor, for all his brilliance, was not always entirely consistent, and it is up to us to research the issue as best we can to develop an informed personal preference as there exists no single right answer. For what it's worth, based on the natural evolution of real languages, I believe it far more likely that both realms spoke a (potentially heavily) accented Sindarin that was understandable by native speakers such as Legolas, but less so by those with lesser proficiency such as Frodo.
 
Kajarotte
Posts: 8
Joined: Wed 29 Apr 2020, 05:35
Location: Hamburg Germany

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Tue 21 Jul 2020, 15:51

Hi Smog,
I found your entire essay on the subject of elven cultures in the regions of Lindon very interesting and well thought out. However, I would disagree with you on one point concerning the mixing of cultures. Even though the time span of 6000 years described above in your post (see quote) may be a long time, I do not find the comparison of the triple time span between us and Christ very helpful for the idea of the mixing of the elven cultures. Elves reproduce, if you go by some prominent examples, quite differently from humans, for whom there would probably be no differences after 6000 years. Elrond, for example, has only 3 children in a period of 6000 years and these have, as far as known, no descendants until the ring war. Also, the question is whether there is something like a dominant culture in terms of descendants, since Elrond, if I am not mistaken, is considered a Noldor, although he is descended from a wide variety of cultures.
Thank you for your detailed post :)

Hi Kajarotte, I'm glad you found the post insightful. I should clarify, however, that you are asserting this mixture of cultures to be generational and the result of those peoples taking spouses and having children across clan lines, but that was not my premise. Indeed, Elves had been doing such a thing as far back as the Years of the Trees, whether it be Finarfin and Earwen (the parents of Felagund and Galadriel) or even Finwe and Indis (for which it would be difficult to find an earlier example).

The huge divide in years was merely to give context to the reader for how long of a span had passed between the end of the First and Third Ages. This was only meant to be considered alongside textual examples that Tolkien provided us about some of the Sindar's integration with their Silvan cousins, such as the following:

"Oropher had come among (the Silvan Elves) with only a handful of Sindar, and they were soon merged with the Silvan Elves, adopting their language and taking names of Silvan form and style. This they did deliberately; for they ... came from Doriath after its ruin, and had no desire to leave Middle-earth, nor to be merged with the other Sindar of Beleriand, dominated by the Noldorin Exiles for whom the folk of Doriath had no great love. They wished indeed to become Silvan folk and to return, as they said, to the simple life natural to the Elves before the invitation of the Valar had disturbed it".
-Unfinished Tales, "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", "Appendix B: The Sindarin Princes of the Silvan Elves", p. 259

So in this passage, we learn a couple things, the most important of which is that cultural appropriation was something that occurred between different Elven peoples. Tolkien states outright that some of the Sindar chose to adapt to more rustic Silvan lifestyles. He also insinuates that some Sindar living among the Noldor had been "dominated" by them, which to me says integrated in a culturally one-sided manner. Another interesting takeaway is that Oropher had a reduced following of Sindar when compared to Amdir and Amroth in Lorinand (Lothlorien), and Celeborn and Galadriel in Ost-in-Edhil prior to their (eventual) further migration to Lorien.

To address your questions concerning Elven marriage and child-rearing frequency, we have far more examples of Elves having children (relatively) early in life rather than late, which was indeed their custom! For numerous examples of this, I would urge you to reference the family trees of the Noldor of the Y.T. and the First Age, but the following passage on the life cycle of Elves will likely also be of interest to you:

"The Eldar brought forth few children; and also that their time of generation was in their youth or earlier life, unless strange and hard fates befell them. But at whatever age they married, their children were born within a short space of years after their wedding."
-Morgoth's Ring, "Part Three. The Later Quenta Silmarillion: (II) The Second Phase: Laws and Customs among the Eldar", p. 212

So as the Professor has stated, it was far more common for Elves to begin bearing children early in life (though early is rather relative, obviously) and shortly after being wed. Of key importance to your specific example is the line "unless strange and hard fates befell them" for which there is hardly a better example than Elrond who was confronted with war and strife for nearly the entirety of the first two ages of the world. However, even that being the case, citing Elrond as only have 3 children in 6000 years is misleading within the greater context of his life. As was the stated Elvish custom, once Elrond finally took Celebrian as his wife in TA 109, they had their first children (Elladan and Elrohir) only 21 years later in TA 130 and Arwen "shortly" after in 241. In summary, it was not the number of years that it took Elrond to have children that was odd, but rather the length of time it took him to marry (in fact, he and Celebrian had met nearly 2000 years prior!). But again, this can largely be attributed to the extremely difficult life he had through the First and Second Ages.

For more information on this topic, I would strongly encourage you to read "Laws and Customs among the Eldar" from Morgoth's Ring. It provides fantastically deep insight into the lives and manners of the Elves that is not matched anywhere else in the Legendarium. For a (regretfully, in my opinion) much reduced summary, you can also read the Tolkien Gateway article on the topic here.

Cheers!
Hi again Smog,

thank you very much for the recommendation. Actually I even own the book, but I haven't read it all yet, because the history of Middleearth is not available in the German translation except for the first two volumes. This unfortunately makes it even less accessible to me than if it were my mother tongue. I think that reading it is anyway not very accessible, as you hear. With the family trees from the Silmarillion I still didn't have the impression that the elves get married and have children so early compared to a human life. I may be wrong there and try to read Morgoths ring as soon as possible. But I can well understand the cultural mixture with regard to the adoption of the customs, as you have described it now. Thanks for the clarification.
 
User avatar
Smog
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri 03 Jul 2020, 19:03
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Tue 21 Jul 2020, 17:13

thank you very much for the recommendation. Actually I even own the book, but I haven't read it all yet, because the history of Middleearth is not available in the German translation except for the first two volumes. This unfortunately makes it even less accessible to me than if it were my mother tongue. I think that reading it is anyway not very accessible, as you hear.

You're welcome! I'm sorry to hear that only the Book of Lost Tales is accessible in German; that sounds very frustrating. That surprises me given Europe's broad following of Tolkien's work.

With the family trees from the Silmarillion I still didn't have the impression that the elves get married and have children so early compared to a human life. I may be wrong there and try to read Morgoths ring as soon as possible.

I can understand your hesitance if this opposes your previous belief on the issue, but the Professor was fairly clear on this point. You must remember that Elves, while immortal, still "grow up" relatively quickly. They are completely matured adults by 50-100 and most (obviously not all) are married and begin having children soon after. You can do some digging on the Tolkien Gateway to work out the math on your own, of course, but here are a few canonical examples:

Parent (Child): Age of the Parent*
=========================
Feanor (Maedhros): 130
Fingolfin (Fingon): 110
Turgon (Idril): 200
Finarfin (Finrod): 70
Angrod (Orodreth): 110

*Note that some of these years are approximations based on other known dates surrounding them (Orodreth), but their margin of error should be small.
 
Kajarotte
Posts: 8
Joined: Wed 29 Apr 2020, 05:35
Location: Hamburg Germany

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Tue 21 Jul 2020, 17:50

To stick with your example: that's an average of about five times the reproductive rate of humans compared to elves. So in 6000 years, elven cultures would mix with each other in about the same way as humans would mix in 1200 years, if the average number of children is not taken into account. That would make a comparison of the duration between us and the early Middle Ages a bit more vivid for me, when it comes to the cultural development in Lindon. Thanks for your sympathy regarding the missing translations of the History of Middle earth. I am not giving up hope for this yet.
 
Dunheved
Posts: 507
Joined: Wed 11 Mar 2020, 02:07
Location: UK

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Sat 25 Jul 2020, 14:10

Considering the OP of this thread, I know that this 'suggestion' is a bit radical.
But, over the many years that TOR1 came out, both with the two book original 'Adventures over the Edge' and the TOR revised single tome, the layout and accessibility of the rules were criticised.

And, repeating the obvious, over those years additional rules came out (and were great, I love evolution) and the most up to date version of the evolved rules became inevitably spread over several different locations. Q: how many books in TOR1 should you consult to decide how to play an attack by warg-riders, mounted by black uruks from Mount Gundabad?

So dare I suggest a ring folder with individual pages that are punched?

1. Would we need for example a bestiary book? Probably not if new monsters and NPCs are introduced on separate pages. The same would apply for other rules; Journeys, Maps,
2. Upgrades of course would simply replace earlier pages as the books and regions arrive.
3. Individual LMs can organise and re-organise their copy as much as they like: they could even extract only the necessary pages for a particular game. Additional copies of certain, heavily used pages could be purchased (or copied I know, but I would pay for copies of some tables etc for other gamers)
4. Proofreading could simply be incorporated without having to completely reprint the entire book every time.
5. 'What If' comments and breakout boxes can be added and removed as suits the LM
6. Alternates (there is a great what if included in the story 'Kinstrife' - I will say no more) (Also more than one way for a certain character to lose his beard might be incorprated)
7. This is of course just me thinking too quickly as I type.... FAN CONTRIBUTIONS might be able to be composed on blank pdfs that could be added
8. Convention packs (a starter kit) might also be easy to be incorporated
9. EXAMPLES of play can be included with comments - and then extracted from the main working file.

Unfortunately I am sure that there are negatives to this idea, I am also sure that many people might take the pdf files and simply print them anyway, making this suggestion redundant.
I too, enjoy a 'proper' book rather than a 'college folder', but I am not looking at this year, when the first book of TOR2e will again be brilliant, well packed with loads of things and some things nobody has considered yet. With that in mind the REGION GUIDES would probably be best as separate books still as they can be composed without additional rules and the sort of information in a region guide does not evolve much that I can remember.

Although I do NOT own it, the Advanced Squad Leader system from Avalon Hill ended up going this way after the fourth component of the system was introduced, making most of the components in the original three parts obsolete. So it really is not an original idea!
 
Otaku-sempai
Posts: 716
Joined: Wed 15 Apr 2020, 15:35
Location: Western New York
Contact:

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Sat 25 Jul 2020, 21:14

I don't think I could see a ring binder as a good solution, especially for the core rules. Pages are easily damaged or lost and both paging and indexing become problematic.
#FideltyToTolkien
 
Lem23
Posts: 53
Joined: Mon 13 Jul 2020, 17:52

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Sat 25 Jul 2020, 22:07

While it's a good idea in theory, in practice when Columbia Games did the same thing with Harn, it got to be a bit cumbersome. I think I'd rather keep things as they are. It's also problematic in that some countries use 2 ring binders as standard, others use 3 ring binders as standard, and others use 4 ring binders.
 
User avatar
Smog
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri 03 Jul 2020, 19:03
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Sun 26 Jul 2020, 10:55

I agree. While I do not want to be dismissive of a creative solution and idea, it becomes cumbersome and honestly feels a bit cheap compared to a nicely bound hardcover book. Personally, if I want to organize things, I just print the desired sections of my purchased pdfs and organize them in whatever way I find helpful. Half of the reason I buy the physical books is just to collect them and keep them on my shelf looking pretty (and to support the publisher/developer, obviously).
 
gyrovague
Posts: 591
Joined: Tue 28 Apr 2020, 16:52

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Mon 27 Jul 2020, 01:22

I love my beautiful hardcovers, even if I use PDFs for reference and at the table.
 
Kazibar
Posts: 11
Joined: Mon 10 Aug 2020, 17:08

Re: My one major peeve with TOR

Mon 10 Aug 2020, 17:16

After 6,000 years I don’t think we can say they will be intermingled at all. These are not Men with a lifetime of 100 years, they are immortal elves. Even Arwen who is accounted young is thousands of years old. [/quote]

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests