Search found 11 matches

  • 1
  • 2
by Olefin
Mon 14 Dec 2020, 04:17
Forum: General
Topic: [ALPHA] My many notes on the Player's Manual
Replies: 69
Views: 15166

Re: [ALPHA] My many notes on the Player's Manual

If food was as scarce as the Players Manual states then the human race would be on the edge of extinction - and the Soviet Forces would be literally eating each other to try to stay alive. Plus those survivors running for the woods would be starved to death in days. The area they have to cover and a...
by Olefin
Mon 14 Dec 2020, 03:46
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

Perhaps a little bit of calm and consideration might be called for. Speculating in categorical statements on what others actually mean by their texts or really are interested in isn't conducive to a constructive discussion — on either side. A clarification could indeed also be called for. The way t...
by Olefin
Mon 14 Dec 2020, 03:33
Forum: General
Topic: [ALPHA] My many notes on the Player's Manual
Replies: 69
Views: 15166

Re: [ALPHA] My many notes on the Player's Manual

Gathering food needs to be completely worked out - the amount of food you can gather and the area you need to look for it sounds like trying to gather food in the Sahara Desert. Not in central and Northern Europe. I have grandparents who during the Great Depression had to eke out what little they co...
by Olefin
Mon 14 Dec 2020, 03:27
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

The entire US carrier is anchored at Stockholm makes no sense at all - its been debated in detail at the forum juhlin site but there is no way - as in ZERO PERCENT - that a US supercarrier woud be going to Stockholm. To get it there we are talking upwards of 100km of sailing, almost every single ste...
by Olefin
Thu 03 Dec 2020, 06:50
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] An attempt at summarizing the world building discussion
Replies: 34
Views: 8954

Re: [ALPHA] An attempt at summarizing the world building discussion

Just thinking about this a little: How is this for a framework to get to a powerful USSR with Warsaw Pact? 1. Start the timeline earlier 2. Perestroika for a couple years, the East Germans or Czechs leave earlier than 1989, Gorbachev is replaced by hard liners. Rest of Warsaw Pact must toe the line...
by Olefin
Thu 03 Dec 2020, 00:18
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

One thing I'd add is the problem of incongruities and the way human imagination works. RPGs settings tend to unravel over time if they have certain in-built incongruities from the outset. As more people apply brain power to a setting, the more it can potentially become unravelled if it's core has v...
by Olefin
Tue 01 Dec 2020, 21:33
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

Great discussion here. I'll just make two quick points: 1. "Plausible" is not an absolute term. What's plausible varies immensely from person to person. No matter what backstory we'd write that ended up with scattered US troops in Poland in the year 2000, it would be called implausible by...
by Olefin
Mon 30 Nov 2020, 06:17
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

and FYI - this timeline is one that includes the US kicking the Iraqi's butts in 1991 - which shows the technological edge the US had over the Soviets - and yet you have the Soviets destroying the US Army and Air Force and Navy - which were so far ahead technologically in the 90's that even Putin ha...
by Olefin
Mon 30 Nov 2020, 06:08
Forum: Referees Only
Topic: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback
Replies: 117
Views: 27304

Re: [ALPHA] THE WORLD AT WAR comments/feedback

The background and timeline and war as presented make a farce of what this was supposed to be about - which is two great power blocs fighting to a stalemate that neither side wins - instead what hou have is a Soviets Uber Alles victory that ends up with no large organized US or NATO forces left of a...
by Olefin
Sat 15 Aug 2020, 02:49
Forum: General
Topic: New sourcebooks/vehicle guides?
Replies: 3
Views: 1905

Re: New sourcebooks/vehicle guides?

Hoping that official published material like the RDF and the East Africa Sourcebook can make it into the canon for the V4 as well as things like the Korean Sourcebook that was recently put out on drivethrurpg.com
  • 1
  • 2